Why Blaming Cartels For Mine Collapses Is Pure Laziness

Why Blaming Cartels For Mine Collapses Is Pure Laziness

Fourteen bodies pulled from a collapsed shaft in Colombia. The headlines roll in with predictable uniformity. Another illegal wildcat mine. Another criminal syndicate operating in the shadows. Another tragedy blamed entirely on greed, guns, and lawlessness.

Save the moral outrage. It misses the target completely. Expanding on this idea, you can also read: The Table Where Borders Are Drawn Without You.

When a hand-dug shaft caves in under a mountain in Antioquia or Cauca, the automatic reflex of policymakers and distant journalists is to point a finger at armed cartels and wash their hands of the mess. This framing treats illegal mining as a localized crime wave driven by bad actors who simply refuse to follow the rules. That diagnosis is dead wrong.

Wildcat mining is not a criminal conspiracy. It is an economic survival strategy built by design. Experts at The Washington Post have also weighed in on this situation.

For decades, I have watched governments across South America treat artisanal extraction as a law enforcement problem rather than a structural failure. When you criminalize subsistence mining without offering a viable alternative economy, you do not eradicate the practice. You drive it underground, strip away every safety baseline, and hand the supply chains straight to violent syndicates. The cartel is not the cause of the disaster. The cartel is the logistics department that steps in to fill a vacuum left by an incompetent state.

Let us look at the mechanics of extraction. Industrial mining operations take years, millions of dollars, and heavy political capital to secure environmental permits. A local family or a cooperative of independent prospectors cannot wait a decade for bureaucratic approval while their children starve. They go where the gold is, shovel in hand, using timber supports that would make a civil engineer weep. They do this because the formal economy locked them out.

Blaming the syndicate for a cave-in is like blaming the black market for high prices during prohibition. It completely ignores the baseline conditions that created the black market in the first place.

The traditional narrative relies on a comfortable fiction. It assumes that if the military simply floods the region, burns the heavy machinery, and locks up every unauthorized miner, the earth will heal and the gold will stay in the ground.

That theory fails the moment it hits reality.

When you destroy a dredge in the Amazon basin without providing employment, the operators simply move fifty yards downriver and start over the next morning with hand tools. When you raid a shaft, you force the miners to dig deeper, faster, and with less structural reinforcement to avoid detection. Every militarized crackdown on informal mining correlates directly with a spike in structural collapses and mercury contamination. The state's hammer does not stop the digging. It makes the digging deadlier.

To understand why these tragedies keep happening, you have to look at the legal framework itself. Colombia and its neighbors designed mining codes that favor massive multinational conglomerates capable of paying massive concession fees and navigating endless layers of environmental oversight. These laws treat artisanal miners not as citizens trying to earn a living, but as poachers stealing national treasure.

That is a fundamental category error. Gold is not a scarce museum artifact guarded by the government. It is a commodity traded on open global exchanges. When the formal market erects an impenetrable fortress around that commodity, the desperate will always find a back door. And the back door is run by men with automatic weapons who do not care about timber bracing or ventilation shafts.

Imagine a scenario where a government treats informal miners the way tech incubators treat software startups. Drop the regulatory barriers to entry. Create fast-track environmental cooperatives. Provide subsidized engineering support, modern shoring equipment, and centralized processing centers that eliminate toxic mercury entirely.

The moment you formalize the informal, you pull the rug out from under the criminal syndicates. Cartels derive their power from isolation and illegality. They cannot charge protection taxes or control supply chains when miners have legal titles, banking access, and government-backed safety inspectors helping them shore up their tunnels.

Instead, the political class prefers the theater of condemnation. Every time a shaft collapses, politicians step in front of microphones to pledge zero tolerance, promise tougher prison sentences, and vow to hunt down the illegal networks. Then the news cycle fades, the permits remain locked behind red tape, and the miners go right back into the unstable earth because eating tomorrow matters more than safety codes today.

This cycle of hypocrisy is staggering. The same global financial markets that buy the gold with no questions asked about its provenance are the first to clutch their pearls when a tunnel gives way. International trade routes absorb dirty gold through shell companies in third-party nations, laundering the metal until it wears a clean corporate halo on Wall Street. The blood on the ore is washed away by the time it hits the bullion exchange.

If we genuinely care about stopping the death toll in places like Antioquia, we have to stop treating this as a war on crime and start treating it as a failure of market access.

Decriminalize the extraction. Syndicate the cooperatives. Bring the underground economy out into the daylight where engineers can inspect the shafts, union rates can protect the workers, and environmental standards can actually be enforced.

Until we stop pretending that police raids can repeal the laws of supply and demand, the mountains will keep falling, the fourteen dead will become forty, and the hypocrites will keep reading the same tired script from the safety of their air-conditioned offices. Stop fighting the miners. Fix the system that makes dying for gold their best option.

YS

Yuki Scott

Yuki Scott is passionate about using journalism as a tool for positive change, focusing on stories that matter to communities and society.