Kathy Hochul did not come to Albany to be a transit savior. Yet, through a series of bruising political reversals, tax compromises, and aggressive security deployments, the New York governor has tethered her political survival to the fate of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Her transformation into an unlikely champion of the New York subway wasn't born out of lifelong urbanist ideology—it was forged by economic necessity, suburban backlash, and the cold reality that New York City’s post-pandemic recovery dies on the tracks if the trains don't run safely and reliably.
When Hochul inherited the governorship in August 2021, few transit advocates expected a revolution. A native of Buffalo with deep political roots in Western New York and suburban Erie County, she represented a constituency where driving is the default and the MTA is often viewed as a bottomless fiscal sinkhole. Early in her tenure, she kept the transit agency at arm's length, treating it more like a budgetary headache than the circulatory system of the state's economic engine. Learn more on a similar topic: this related article.
That distance vanished when the numbers stopped adding up. By 2023, the MTA was staring down a catastrophic fiscal cliff driven by permanent shifts in remote work. Farebox revenue—historically the backbone of the agency's operating budget—had collapsed by hundreds of millions of dollars annually. Without a massive infusion of recurring state revenue, the MTA faced doomsday scenarios: slashing subway and bus service by up to 40 percent, laying off thousands of workers, or jacking up fares to punitive levels.
Hochul realized quickly that a collapsing subway system meant a collapsing Midtown Manhattan tax base. And a collapsing Midtown tax base meant massive budget deficits for the entire state of New York, from Long Island to Buffalo. Further journalism by NPR delves into similar perspectives on this issue.
The Payroll Tax Rescue and the Political Tightrope
To pull the agency back from the brink, Hochul engineered a massive bailout in the 2023 state budget that permanently altered how New York funds mass transit. Rather than relying on one-time federal pandemic aid that was rapidly evaporating, she pushed through an increase to the Payroll Mobility Tax on the largest businesses operating within New York City, raising the rate from 0.34 percent to 0.60 percent.
It was a politically treacherous move. Business groups warned of an exodus of corporate headquarters to Florida and Texas, while suburban lawmakers in Long Island and the Hudson Valley revolted against any tax hikes touching their districts. Hochul threaded the needle by exempting the suburban counties from the rate increase, placing the financial burden squarely on major corporations inside the five boroughs. Coupled with increased contributions from New York City and dedicated shares of future downstate casino licensing revenues, the package generated roughly $1.1 billion in new annual operating revenue for the MTA.
For a governor who had initially been viewed with skepticism by transit advocates, the payroll tax hike was a decisive turning point. She didn't just patch a hole; she restructured the agency's revenue floor. By freezing planned fare hikes to a modest four percent instead of double-digit spikes and expanding pilot programs for fare-free bus routes, she signaled that keeping riders in the system mattered more than squeezing them at the turnstile.
Yet, money alone couldn't solve the perception crisis underground.
Security Theater or Necessary Deterrence
While ridership crept back toward 70 to 75 percent of pre-pandemic baselines, a string of high-profile, random violent crimes on subway platforms dominated local tabloid front pages and evening newscasts. Even when overall transit crime statistics fluctuated within historical norms, the visceral fear of being pushed onto the tracks or assaulted during a morning commute threatened to undo every dollar spent on fiscal stabilization.
Hochul’s response was blunt and deeply controversial. In March 2024, she deployed 750 members of the New York National Guard, alongside State Police officers, into the busiest subway stations to conduct random bag checks alongside the NYPD.
Civil liberties organizations and progressive lawmakers immediately condemned the move as heavy-handed militarization that criminalized poverty and disproportionately targeted Black and brown commuters. Transit experts questioned whether soldiers in fatigues standing near turnstiles actually deterred the specific types of acute mental health crises driving the most erratic subway violence.
Hochul refused to blink. She understood a fundamental truth about urban politics that technocrats often miss: perception is policy. If suburban commuters and outer-borough workers do not feel safe descending the stairs into a station, fare freezes and new subway cars are irrelevant. Alongside the troop deployment, she pushed through legislation allowing judges to ban individuals convicted of assaulting transit workers from riding the subway, and she accelerated the installation of security cameras inside every single subway car across the fleet.
Was it partially political theater aimed at neutralizing Republican talking points ahead of crucial congressional elections in the New York suburbs? Undoubtedly. Did it reassure a jittery riding public enough to keep weekday ridership climbing past the four-million mark? Transit analysts and business improvement districts largely agreed that visible uniformity at station entrances calmed immediate panic, even as critics demanded long-term investments in psychiatric beds and supportive housing rather than rifle-toting guardsmen.
The Congestion Pricing Whiplash
If the 2023 bailout cemented Hochul’s reputation as a transit defender, her handling of congestion pricing nearly destroyed it overnight—and paradoxically forced her to double down on the subway's future.
Scheduled to launch in June 2024, Manhattan’s Central Business District Tolling Program was designed to charge most passenger vehicles $15 to enter Manhattan below 60th Street. The policy had two explicit goals: reduce gridlock in the nation’s most congested core and generate $15 billion in bonded capital funding to modernize the subway's century-old signal systems, add elevators for disability access, and extend the Second Avenue Subway into East Harlem.
Then, just weeks before the cameras were set to flip on, Hochul pulled the emergency brake. Citing inflation, the high cost of living for working-class outer-borough drivers, and fears that the toll would choke Manhattan’s fragile economic recovery, she placed an indefinite pause on the program.
The backlash was volcanic. Transit advocates, environmental groups, and editorial boards accused her of bowing to political pressure from suburban swing districts and betraying a decade of infrastructure planning. Worse, the pause instantly blew a $15 billion hole in the MTA’s 2020–2024 capital program. Without that bonded revenue, the agency was forced to freeze contracts for brand-new electric buses, halt ADA accessibility upgrades at dozens of stations, and delay critical signal modernization projects on the A, C, B, D, F, and M lines.
For several tense months, Hochul looked less like a subway champion and more like an erratic executive trapped between competing constituencies.
When she finally resurrected the program months later—slashing the base passenger toll from $15 down to $9 while preserving the legal mechanism to bond out the full $15 billion for the MTA—it revealed the cold pragmatism driving her entire tenure. She realized there was no alternative pot of gold sitting in Albany. State lawmakers had zero appetite to raise income taxes or divert highway funds from upstate districts to pay for New York City subway signals. The only way to save the MTA's capital budget, and avoid devastating lawsuits from transit groups, was to get the tolling gantries running at a politically survivable price point.
The Hidden Crisis Inside the Capital Budget
By rescuing the $15 billion capital stream through the revised congestion toll, Hochul averted an immediate infrastructure freeze. However, the episode exposed a much deeper structural vulnerability that will define her legacy long after the political noise fades: the MTA's staggering cost of construction.
New York builds transit infrastructure at a price per mile that dwarfs every other major metropolis on earth. While cities like Paris, Madrid, and London expand rail networks and modernize stations at manageable costs, the MTA routinely spends billions on single-station renovations and tunnel extensions. Excessive overtime rules, rigid union work jurisdictions, sprawling layers of private consultants, and bespoke station designs have turned basic maintenance into luxury spending.
Hochul has repeatedly pressed MTA leadership to rein in these costs, yet the agency’s subsequent 2025–2029 Capital Plan still ballooned to more than $68 billion—the largest in its history. That massive price tag isn't for flashy new lines crisscrossing the boroughs; the vast majority of it is required simply to keep a 120-year-old system from crumbling. Rolling stock dating back to the 1970s and 1980s must be replaced. Ancient switching equipment from the Great Depression era still dictates train speeds on major trunk lines, causing cascading delays whenever a single signal fails. Substations need waterproofing to survive increasingly violent coastal storms.
Supporting the subway in this environment requires more than signing off on tax hikes or deployment orders. It demands taking on entrenched institutional habits inside the transit authority itself—a fight that brings very little political reward and plenty of powerful enemies.
Why Hochul Cannot Afford to Walk Away
Critics on the left still view Hochul as a reluctant convert who only embraces progressive urban policies when cornered by fiscal reality. Critics on the right paint her as an enabler of a bloated, unaccountable transit bureaucracy that endlessly demands more money from taxpayers.
Both critiques miss the larger strategic picture. Hochul’s evolution into a fiercely protective steward of the New York subway isn't a mystery; it is basic arithmetic.
New York State relies disproportionately on high earners and corporations concentrated in Manhattan to fund schools, Medicaid, and infrastructure across all 62 counties. Those companies only stay in Manhattan if their workforce can move efficiently through the city. When subway delays spike or stations feel unsafe, corporate lease renewals stall, commercial real estate values drop, and state tax receipts shrink.
Hochul learned early in her administration that you cannot govern New York State from a bunker in Albany while ignoring the tunnels beneath Fifth Avenue. Whether deploying state troopers to calm commuter nerves, muscling a corporate payroll tax through a reluctant legislature, or recalibrating congestion pricing to keep capital dollars flowing, her decisions have consistently prioritized keeping the system solvent and operational.
She may never look or sound like a traditional transit evangelist, and her zig-zags on tolling proved she remains acutely sensitive to suburban political winds. Yet, when the MTA faced existential financial collapse and political abandonment, Kathy Hochul made the calculated bet that her governorship would rise or fall with the trains. In New York politics, there is no getting off that ride early.